Local Government Lawyer

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

Lawyers representing a couple who run three independent cafés around Hampstead Heath that are due to be taken over by a chain have confirmed they have dropped their case against the City of London Corporation.

‘Hoxton Beach’, owned and run by Patrick Matthews and Emma Fernandez, has been operating the Lido Kiosk Café at Parliament Hill since April 2018, the Refreshment Pavilion at Queen’s Park since autumn 2018, and the Highgate Wood Café since May 2019.  

In July 2025, the City of London Corporation (CLC) announced that it would be reviewing the tenders of the cafés as part of a re-marketing process, and invited applications to operate the cafes. 

In September, Hoxton Beach submitted its application to continue running the cafés and in December Mr Matthews and Ms Fernandez were informed that the company’s leases would not be renewed.  

According to Leigh Day, this decision was formally communicated in January 2026, with café chain Daisy Green set to take over and Hoxton Beach given just four weeks' notice to vacate.  

However, Matthews and Fernandez subsequently claimed that the Corporation failed to carry out a “fair or transparent process”.

Earlier this year, lawyers representing Hoxton Beach submitted an application for a judicial review.

This week, Matthews and Fernandez said a judge had reviewed the claim and granted permission for it to proceed.

However, the couple said they would not pursue the judicial process, adding that the "personal and financial costs [had] become too great", according to the BBC.

Leigh Day solicitor Ellie Fawcett, who represents Hoxton Beach's owners, said: "While Hoxton Beach was granted permission to proceed on four grounds, it has taken the difficult decision not to continue this case to a final hearing. This decision was reached only after very careful consideration of all relevant factors. It is deeply disappointing that Hoxton Beach's much-loved cafés, which have served and contributed to their local communities for many years, will now have to close.

"Throughout this process, Hoxton Beach has sought to stand up for its family-owned business, its staff and the communities it serves, and it remains grateful to everyone who has supported them throughout this process."

A spokesperson for the City of London Corporation, the trustee of the Hampstead Heath, Highgate Wood and Queen’s Park charities, said: “Our process was lawful, open, and the only fair and proper way to secure the future of all five cafés.

“Daisy Green and Cosmin Stuparu submitted the strongest proposals and demonstrated the best long-term plans for these important sites.

“It is regrettable that charitable resources have been diverted into legal proceedings.

“Our focus is on delivering an improved café service, with investment in the facilities, affordable options, and all staff paid at least the London Living Wage.”

Hoxton Beach has been approached for comment.

Lottie Winson

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Directory

Newsletter signup