Legal challenge over Down Syndrome Act and alleged discrimination against children with other rare genetic conditions to be heard in High Court
- Details
The High Court is today (17 November) scheduled to hear a legal challenge arguing that the Down Syndrome Act 2022 unlawfully discriminates against people with other genetic conditions who have similar health, educational and social care needs, by providing statutory protections specifically for individuals with Down syndrome.
Represented by law firm Irwin Mitchell, two children with rare genetic conditions have been granted permission to take their legal challenge against the Government to the High Court.
The challenge has been brought on behalf of a 14-year-old girl living with Pitt-Hopkins Syndrome who requires specialist education and one-to-one support, and a toddler with Williams Syndrome, a rare condition that can affect development, learning and physical health.
Their families say both children face challenges comparable to those experienced by many people with Down syndrome and require similar support from healthcare, education and social care services.
Irwin Mitchell said: “The case concerns the Down Syndrome Act 2022; legislation which requires public authorities to have regard to guidance designed to meet the needs of people with Down syndrome. The claimants argue that by focusing solely on Down syndrome, the law treats people with other comparable genetic conditions differently without objective justification.”
The claim argues that the legislation breaches Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits discrimination, because there is no objective justification for treating individuals with Down syndrome differently from those with other comparable genetic conditions.
According to the law firm, the case raises questions over whether the protections linked to the Act should apply more broadly to people with comparable genetic conditions.
Ryan Westwell, a public law expert at Irwin Mitchell representing the families, said: “This is an important case about equal treatment and whether people with genetic conditions that create similar challenges and support needs should be afforded the same recognition and consideration under the law.
"Our clients are not seeking to diminish the rights of people with Down syndrome. They simply want to ensure that other children and adults with equally complex genetic conditions are not left behind.
"The High Court’s permission decision means these issues will now receive detailed judicial scrutiny, in a case that could have important implications for families affected by rare genetic conditions.”
Irwin Mitchell has instructed Steve Broach KC and Eliza Sharron from 39 Essex Chambers for the hearing.
The Department for Health and Social Care has been approached for comment.
Lottie Winson
Legal Adviser – Economic Crime and Confiscation Unit
Civil Litigation Lawyer
Lawyer
Generalist Lawyer
Litigation Lawyer (Civil and Criminal)
Locums


