Local Government Lawyer

The High Court has allowed a judicial review claim brought by a disabled Somerset resident over the local authority’s council tax reduction scheme.

In Andy Mitchell, R (on the application of) v Somerset Council [2026] EWHC 2930 (Admin), Judge Barry Clarke concluded that the defendant failed to comply with section 149 of the Equality Act 2010 in adopting the scheme for 2025/26, and ordered that the decision regarding the claimant’s council tax liability made under the scheme be quashed.

The claim for judicial review concerned council tax, and the help that local councils must give to residents who cannot afford to pay it.

Most households in England must pay council tax to their local council. Since 2013, however, every council that collects the tax has had to operate its own scheme for reducing the bills of residents in financial need. Such a scheme is called a council tax reduction (CTR) scheme.

For people of working age, each council decides for itself, within limits set by Parliament, who is helped and by how much.

Judge Barry Clarke said: “The question in this case is whether two rules of the scheme operated by Somerset Council (the defendant), and the way in which the defendant applied them to Mr Mitchell (the claimant), are lawful.”

Mr Mitchell brought the claim after the council dramatically reduced the level of council tax support he received when he was migrated from legacy benefits onto Universal Credit.  

Prior to the move to Universal Credit, the claimant did not have to pay council tax under Somerset Council’s reduction scheme, but after being reassessed under the council’s current rules, he became liable for more than £1,100 a year in council tax despite there being no change in his circumstances, income or needs. 

Law firm Leigh Day, which represented the claimant, said: “This was because two elements of his Universal Credit, the limited capability for work-related activity element and the transitional element, which he receives as a result of his disability, were suddenly counted as spare income for the purposes of calculating his ability to pay council tax.”

The claimant challenged two decisions of the defendant.

The first was the decision of its full council on 18 December 2024, which adopted the scheme for the year beginning 1 April 2025.

The second was the decision of 10 September 2025, which determined how much council tax he must pay for that year.

The claimant asked the court to quash the second decision, but not the scheme itself.

He also sought declarations that the defendant acted unlawfully, and damages for injury to his feelings.

The claimant relied on the grounds that the council’s scheme was irrational and unlawfully disadvantaged disabled people, and that the council had failed to properly consider the impact of its scheme on disabled people in line with its duties under the Equality Act.

The council resisted the claim on numerous grounds, including that the claim came too late.

Considering the claim, Judge Barry Clarke held that the rules in Somerset Council’s 2025/26 council tax reduction scheme are “irrational and discriminatory”, because they treat people who have identical needs differently based on the type of benefit they receive, without justification.

The judge also found that the Exceptional Hardship scheme, which Somerset operates to assist individuals struggling to pay their council tax, does not remove or substantially mitigate the severe impact of this difference in treatment on disabled people.

Additionally, the judge concluded that the council failed to comply with its duty under section 149 of the Equality Act to have ‘due regard’ to the needs of disabled people, and found that the claim was brought “promptly”.

He said: “The decision of 10 September 2025 is quashed; declarations will be made in terms to be approved by the court; and the claimant is entitled in principle to damages for injury to feelings. The defendant must determine the claimant’s liability for 2025/26 afresh, in accordance with this judgment.”

Carolin Ott, who represented Mr Mitchell together with Aurelia Buelens, said: “This is an important judgment for disabled people and others who rely on council tax reduction schemes to make ends meet. The court has recognised that Somerset Council’s scheme operated unlawfully and that people should not lose vital support simply because they have been migrated from legacy benefits onto Universal Credit. It has also highlighted the importance of considering the impact of proposed rules on disabled people.

“The issues raised by Andy’s case are not unique to Somerset. Other local authorities operate schemes that take a similar approach and we expect this judgment to have significant implications beyond Somerset.”

Responding to the judgment, Cllr Liz Leyshon, Somerset Council's Lead Member for Finance, Procurement & Performance, said: “This case came forward following national changes to benefits which impacted on some local recipients of council tax reduction.

“Supporting residents in need always comes first, but this matter was complex and we believed we responded in the most appropriate way. However, we acknowledge the court’s judgement and recognise the impact of the changes on Mr Mitchell.

 “Our immediate priority is to address Mr Mitchell’s case, ensure council tax reduction is being assessed lawfully, and establish whether any other residents may be affected."

Cllr Leyshon added: “This ruling raises important questions about how national decisions have impacted on local council tax reduction schemes across the country, and we are considering whether there are any aspects of the judgment which a higher court should be asked to look at. 

“[…] We remain committed to supporting residents who may need help with their council tax. We will review our draft Council Tax Reduction Scheme for 2027/28 in light of this judgment, with proposals to be considered by Executive in early December.”

Lottie Winson

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Directory

Newsletter signup