Local Government Lawyer

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

Sheffield City Council has secured a small increase in penalties for failure to comply with improvement notices after the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) found the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) failed to explain why it considered the harms from remaining defects were rated ‘medium’ rather than ‘high’.

The case was brought by the council after married couple Masoud El-Saadawy and Thanna Lasheen, who own a house converted to two flats, had succeeded at the FTT in having the penalties reduced by more than 75%.

Martin Rodger KC, deputy chamber president, said in his ruling the FTT had inspected the properties to understand the context and problems,”yet it did not make any specific findings of fact about the works which had not been completed and did not explain why it considered the harm which they caused fell into the medium band. 

“It was incumbent on the FTT to explain why it took the view it did, not least because it was disagreeing with the council's assessment. The FTT's decision cannot stand.”

Sheffield had imposed penalties of £11,700 on each of the couple for non-compliance with an improvement notice and further penalties of £9,900 on Mr El-Saadawy and £11,700 on Mrs Lasheen for failure to comply with a second improvement notice.

A complaint by a tenant about damp and mould prompted an inspection by housing officers, who identified what they considered to be category 1 and 2 hazards. All the remedial work required was found completed by a third inspection in June 2024.   

Sheffield had concluded this was a medium/high culpability case according to its policy for calculating penalties.

The couple appealed to the FTT which found the penalties imposed “do not reasonably reflect the efforts [they] made and the difficulties they faced in complying with the improvement notices, particularly considering that penalties are imposed on each [respondent] in respect of the same properties”.

It considered the starting figure for the penalties should be £10,000 but reduced by 75% to take into account mitigating factors, which included prompt provision of the gas and electricity safety certificates and the landlords’ health issues. This process concluded with penalties of £2,500 each, giving a total of £10,000.

Mr Rodger found the FTT failed to properly explain its reasoning for why the defects were not ‘high’- and so subject to a higher starting figure.

He remade the decision and said the couple should pay £3,750 each for each offence making the total payable £7,500, rather than £5,000 as determined by the FTT.

But he dismissed all Sheffield’s other grounds of appeal. Mr Rodger said a claim that the FTT impermissibly reasoned back from a pre-determined outcome had “no substance” being based on “a blinkered reading of a single paragraph in the decision and ignores the exercise which follows, in which the FTT worked through the matters which the policy identified as material and reached its own conclusion”.

Mr Rodger also dismissed an argument that the FTT failed to sufficiently explain its 75% reduction for mitigating factors.

He said: “The council considered that the fact that the respondents were a couple and were being penalised for very similar offences in respect of two flats in the same building justified a reduction of 35% for one of the flats but only 10% for the other, without explaining what, if any, reasons it had for the difference. 

“The choice of 35% rather than 25% or 50% is probably incapable of explanation on any basis other than that it is the figure which feels right to the decision maker.

“The council had made deductions of 55% and 65% for mitigation.  The FTT added three additional factors to the four taken into account by the council and attributed a total of 75% to all those it mentioned.  Given that all but one of the council's adjustments was either 5% or 10% it is not difficult to account for the differences between the outcomes which are entirely explained by the FTT having given similar weight to a small number of extra mitigating factors.  

He further rejected grounds that the FTT erred in its assessment of culpability and of harm and in its treatment of aggravating factors.

Mark Smulian

Must read

LGL Red line

Sponsored articles

LGL Red line

Jobs

Directory

Newsletter signup