Local Government Lawyer

A beach venue operator has launched a legal challenge against BCP Council, claiming the procurement process behind the award of a 20-year lease for its site to another business was unlawful.

Macemade Ltd has operated a venue named SOBO Beach on the site at Southbourne Beach since 2022.

However, it lost out to a rival firm in a bid to secure a 20-year lease for the site in June this year.

Macemade has now issued proceedings in the High Court, which has resulted in the automatic suspension of contractual execution under the Procurement Act 2023.

This means the council cannot currently enter into the proposed long-term agreement while the suspension remains in force, unless it is lifted or otherwise ends through the legal process.

The exact legal grounds of Macemade’s claim are not known.

A spokesperson for Macemade Ltf, confirmed it had issued High Court proceedings against the council, adding: "SOBO Beach believe that the procurement of this contract was legally flawed and will be requesting the High Court to uphold its challenge."

Campaign group Save SOBO Beach welcomed the suspension, but said questions remain over whether the local authority can demonstrate it followed its own policies, procedures and financial safeguards when making the procurement decision.

Commenting on the legal challenge, a BCP Council spokesperson said: “We have been informed that on the evening of Tuesday 10 November solicitors acting for Macemade Ltd have filed legal proceedings in relation to the contract award process relating to the Southbourne beach cafe.

“In light of those proceedings, the contract award will be paused while the court process is ongoing and until the matter has been determined.

“The council remains confident that the procurement process was conducted appropriately and in accordance with the relevant legal and regulatory requirements. As the matter is now subject to legal proceedings, it would not be appropriate to comment further at this stage.”

Alongside Macemade’s procurement challenge, Save SOBO Beach said it remains in discussions with solicitors regarding a potential separate judicial review.

A spokesperson for the group said it is examining whether there are distinct public law grounds concerning the council’s property-approval decisions, the information provided to councillors and its governance responsibilities "that are not adequately addressed by the existing procurement proceedings".

It added: "We have consistently sought to resolve these matters cooperatively through openness, proper scrutiny and constructive dialogue, but in the absence of any transparency on the issue, legal action becomes a possible route to accountability."

Adam Carey

Sponsored articles

LGL Red line

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Directory

Events

Newsletter signup