Judge refuses councils permission for judicial review challenge over largest solar farm in UK
- Details
The High Court has refused Lincolnshire County Council and North Kesteven District Council permission to challenge the Government’s approval of what would be the UK’s largest solar farm.
The two local authorities had sought to advance nine grounds of challenge to the approval of Springwell Solar Farm.
On 8 April this year, the then Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, Ed Miliband, approved plans for a solar farm covering 1,280 hectares of land near Scopwick.
Lincolnshire and North Kesteven said five of their proposed grounds of challenge related to the Navenby Substation.
In a statement they said: “The Government’s Inspector insisted that a requirement for planning consent was necessary to make a development acceptable, but the Secretary of State removed this from the approved Development Consent Order for Springwell Solar Farm.
“The Judge recognised the councils’ concerns that this could result in solar development with no guarantee that there would be a substation in place to connect the power to the grid.
“However, none of these grounds were considered arguable as the Judge concluded that National Policy Statements set out the importance and urgency of critical national infrastructure.”
The other grounds related to food security, which Lincolnshire and North Kesteven argued had been underplayed in the decision-making process by the Secretary of State.
At the preliminary hearing, the councils also sought to highlight that there was no information relating to food security impacts in Springwell’s Environmental Statement.
“The Judge ruled that all the councils’ grounds relating to food security were not arguable, as the Secretary of State was entitled to give limited weight in his decision, and the Planning Inspectorate had not requested the specific information to be included in an Environmental Statement,” the two councils said.
The local authorities admitted that they “now have no realistic routes” left to challenge approval for the solar farm.
Cllr Sean Matthews, Leader of Lincolnshire County Council, said: “Given the size of this development, I’m disappointed that our councils will not have the opportunity to present a case at a full hearing.
“The impact of this development won’t be felt in London, where all these decisions have been made. Rather, residents across dozens of rural communities now face the likelihood of huge industrial solar farms appearing on their doorstep.
Cllr Richard Wright, Leader of North Kesteven District Council, said: “We are naturally deeply disappointed that the court has today dismissed our request to move forward with a Judicial Review into the Government’s approval of the UK’s largest solar farm within our area.
“Both North Kesteven District Council and Lincolnshire County Council argued strongly during the planning process, against the development, saying that it did not properly assess the impacts on affected rural villages and landscapes, or adequately take onto account the cumulative impact of developments in Lincolnshire, which continue to use large amounts of the best and most versatile agricultural land.
“It was our case to the courts that through the Examining Authority’s report and Secretary of State’s decision letter, proper process was not followed and the decision was unsound.”
Cllr Wright added: "I have no regrets in raising our concerns on this issue with the court. It is not a decision that we took lightly and it was done following legal advice and a careful consideration of the potential costs and impact. We felt that we had grounds to challenge the decision, believing that proper process was not followed, and it was important for this to be tested."
Sponsored articles
Walker Morris supports Tower Hamlets Council in first known Remediation Contribution Order application issued by local authority
Generalist Lawyer
Property Solicitor
Lawyer
Locums
16-11-2026
23-11-2026
26-11-2026 4:00 pm
To Be Confirmed


