Local Government Lawyer

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

The High Court has given important guidance as to the circumstances in which a gambling operator may be held liable in damages for harm to a gambler, writes Philip Kolvin KC.

Background

A person engaging in gambling may be vulnerable for a number of reasons. They may gamble more they want to. They may gamble more than they can afford to. Or their decisions regarding their gambling might be affected by a temporary or permanent illness or disability. Obviously, this may include where they have a gambling disorder. In an extreme case, this may result in a gambler taking their own life as a result of their gambling and/or their losses.

These are always distressing cases, and are dealt with in different ways in legal processes.

First, operators may be held to have breached conditions or codes of practice set by the national regulator, the Gambling Commission, which can result in a review of their operating licences and sanctions including financial penalties, additional conditions on their operating licences, suspension or revocation. Alleged breaches may include failing to interact sufficiently or at all with their customer when they have reason to suppose that the customer is vulnerable, or failing to respect a self-exclusion agreement whereby the customer tries to stay clear of gambling or inducements to gamble.

Second, operators may be drawn into inquests, which may result in findings that the gambling was a cause of death, and/or a prevention of future deaths report by the Coroner setting out recommendations for steps that should be taken to avoid future harms.

The third way is an action for damages, brought by a living claimant or their executor or dependants where tragically they have taken their own lives. This third path, while trodden in the past, has not proved successful.

In particular, in Calvert v William Hill Credit Limited [2008] EWHC 454 (Ch), the High Court rejected a claim for damages by a gambler seeking to recover his losses. It declined to rule that there was a wide duty to take reasonable steps to offer assistance to problem gamblers. It accepted only that there was a duty to a customer whose behaviour has become so extreme as to demonstrate to the operator that his gambling is wholly outside his control – a state of affairs which were not made out on the facts of the case. The Court was also prepared to accept that an operator which voluntarily assumes a duty to a gambler, e.g. by agreeing to exclude him from gambling, should be held to that duty. However, on the question of causation, the defendant’s breach had caused no loss, because the claimant would still have gambled in other ways and/or with other operators even if excluded from certain channels by the defendant. This finding was appealed unsuccessfully to the Court of Appeal at [2008] EWCA Civ 1427.

Ashton v TSE Malta LLP [2026] EWHC 2935

This case represented a challenge to the principles established in Calvert.

The circumstances were tragic. Mr Ashton lost substantial sums gambling and ultimately took his own life. His wife, and principal claimant, had believed he was only an occasional gambler and, after she learned of the amount of his gambling, believed that he had then ceased gambling altogether, which proved not to be the case. The basis of the claim was that the defendant, a company with which he had gambled, had negligently failed to intervene in his gambling, which had caused or contributed to his death.

The Court considered that the duty of care asserted by the claimants was indistinguishable from that considered and rejected in Calvert. Therefore, in substance the case principally concerned whether a wider duty should now be declared by the Court.

In considering this, the Judge, Swift J, pointed out that there was a principle of respect for personal autonomy. A gambler chooses to gamble, and gambling is a lawful activity, with the risk of problem gambling to be addressed by public regulation by the Gambling Commission. While a gambler might make choices others may regard as unwise, that is their prerogative. For these main reasons, the Court was not prepared to adopt a wider approach to duty of care than was declared in Calvert.

The Court acknowledged that the threshold for liability for sanction by the Gambling Commission might be lower than the threshold for a duty of care in Court. It did not view that as a problem to be eradicated. To the contrary, to adopt a duty which simply replicated the obligations under gambling legislation would usurp the position and role of the Gambling Commission, and for that reason would be an inappropriate development of the common law.

On the facts, having heard conflicting medical evidence, the Court did not find that Mr Ashton had a gambling disorder, and therefore the narrow duty of care accepted in Calvert was not triggered. This meant that there was not necessary for the Court to give close consideration to the questions of whether the standard of care was met, or whether any breach had caused loss, or whether there was contributory fault. Further, as the Court pointed out, there being no sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that Mr Ashton suffered from gambling disorder, there was no possible basis on which the requirement for foreseeability could be met.

Discussion

The case of Ashton is a deeply sad one. Following an inquest, the Coroner issued a Prevention of Future Deaths report stating his concern that player protection tools had been inadequate. The case should not be seen as lowering the standards which operators have to meet vis a vis their regulator. But it is a reaffirmation that it will only be in the most exceptional circumstances that tortious liabilities will be incurred by an operator to a gambler, their estate or their dependants.

Philip Kolvin KC is a barrister at 11KBW.

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Directory

Newsletter signup