Local Government Lawyer

 

Government Legal Department Senior Roles

The Government’s independently commissioned Milburn Review has called for strategic authorities in England to coordinate new youth participation plans to support young people.

Youth participation requirements should also be embedded in public procurement, it said.

A 267-page report, authored by Alan Milburn and published on Tuesday, set out a series of proposals to change how public institutions track the progress of and support young people through education and into employment.

Milburn’s independent findings seek to tackle what the report described as the ‘NEET Crisis’. NEET stands for ‘not in education, employment, or training’.

His report said, among other things, that responsibility for young people is too fragmented between institutions, programmes and tiers of government.

It added: “Education, health and welfare operate in separate silos and magnify the very problem they are supposed to help solve.

“Each plays its own role but the young person still falls through the gaps. While Britain has institutions for young people, there is no active participation system capable of carrying them from childhood into working life.”

To address this, the review recommended a single ‘participation system for early adulthood’, run by strategic authorities.

Strategic authorities in England should be responsible for the participation system across ages 16 to 24 within their areas, with local authorities remaining the local backbone and retaining their statutory responsibilities for 16 and 17-year-olds, it said.

“This extension to age 24 is a fundamental change. At present, the state’s responsibility for young people falls away after age 18.”

The new system would see mayors work through one shared ‘Area Youth Participation Plan’, agreed with their constituent councils, the NHS, education and skills providers, employment services, employers, the voluntary sector and young people.

The report added: “There will be new institutions and new laws needed to help make all this happen. Strategic authorities, working with local authorities, will have new accountabilities, powers and resources to drive forward local efforts to reduce NEET rates.

“A Youth Opportunity Test will ensure laws and regulations enable rather than inhibit participation. Public procurement rules will have youth participation requirements embedded at their heart.

“New entitlements for young people to a decent opportunity and a proper level of support will have legal force. A Youth Opportunity Service in all parts of the country will be created to deliver them. This is the new engine room of a working state.”

Elsewhere, the report noted that there are unresolved constitutional questions over who is responsible for what and where decision-making best rests between the local and the national.

It also said that councils need more funding and wider powers in order to support young people, stating: “Local authorities have some legal duties but frequently lack both the fiscal headroom and authority over key institutions to drive a whole-system response. Meanwhile, many mayors and strategic authorities are new, do not cover the whole country and have ambiguous levels of control over key decisions.”

Milburn meanwhile “fully endorsed” the Government’s planned reforms to the SEND system, stating that support currently depends too much on cross diagnostic or administrative thresholds.

The report said: “Diagnosis can be valuable, but families should not have to fight for a label before practical help becomes available. The test should increasingly be whether a young person is attending, learning, experiencing the wider world and moving towards participation.”

Responding to the report, Cllr Eamonn O'Brien, Chair of the LGA, said that councils across England, including those in devolution areas working closely with strategic authorities, need a clearly defined role in the design and delivery of any new system.

He said: “They have the convening powers and knowledge of communities and employers, and need adequate resources and time to deliver.

“Better support for young people must look at the whole system, including any forthcoming welfare reform that supports them into work, training or education.”

James Arrowsmith, Partner in social care at Browne Jacobson, meanwhile said the report rightly diagnosed the NEET crisis as the “product of multiple, interconnected failures”, adding that the neighbourhood working model the government is already pursuing in health and care would help tackle the fragmentation Milburn criticises.

He said: “The question for local leaders in councils, ICBs and combined authorities is whether the work already under way on neighbourhood health and care can be consciously aligned with the system Milburn is proposing.

“There is a real risk that two streams of ambition, both pointing in the same direction, end up running in parallel rather than converging. The frameworks to begin that alignment already exist. What is needed now is the strategic will to use them together.”

Adam Carey

Directory

Newsletter signup