Local Government Lawyer

A new report by the County Councils Network (CCN) has called for greater recognition of the complexity and costs of neighbourhood health planning in county and rural areas, warning that “urban-centric policies” may not be feasible in these areas.

Under new plans published by the Government last week (12 November), local councils will be tasked with arranging social care in people’s homes in a smaller geographical area or ‘neighbourhood’.

Currently, councils can commission individual visits from multiple providers spread across large areas.

People may therefore see different carers across multiple days, while workers can spend significant parts of their day travelling between appointments, the Government said.

In a report published today (16 November), CCN observed that county and rural areas contain “unique and diverse populations, geographies, infrastructure, workforces, and care markets”.

The report therefore calls on the government to ensure funding settlements and allocations “fairly reflect the costs of planning and delivering neighbourhood health in rural and coastal areas” - including the increased costs associated with distance, travel times, workforce pressures and dispersed services.

According to CCN, the government has allocated £50m to the first phase of its Neighbourhood Health Centre programme, with the majority of this distributed to city or urban-based provision.

In light of this, the report calls for a “parallel investment” into realising the opportunities of neighbourhood health in rural areas, through mechanisms such as hub-and-spoke arrangements, mobile units and outreach, digital provision, and bolstering third sector infrastructure.

Meanwhile, the report calls for councils to be at the forefront of shaping local plans.

It argues that neighbourhood health is their “core business” - with upper-tier authorities having responsibility for public health, children’s services and adult social care, as well as the wider determinants of health, such as public transport and housing.

Based on an examination of existing planning for neighbourhood health, the report concludes that the most effective approaches depend on closer collaboration between the NHS, councils and local partners, and have three essential ingredients: relationships, governance, and resource.

The report makes the following recommendations for national leaders and policy makers:

  • Make local flexibility explicit in national guidance;
  • Clarify accountability without prescribing one organisational model;
  • Recognise the additional costs of accessible provision in county, rural and coastal areas;
  • Protect planning and commissioning capacity during reform;
  • Enable investment in prevention and communities.

Cllr Bill Revans, Adult Social Care and Health Spokesperson for the County Councils Network, said: “This report highlights some of the effective neighbourhood health planning that is taking place in county areas up and down the country, delivering better local services and ensuring we have healthier communities. In the context of the NHS 10 Year Health Plan, this report is a timely assessment of what approaches are working, what can be improved upon, and how we can navigate changing structures as public services are reformed.

“The report is clear that improved neighbourhood health cannot be achieved by the NHS alone. Councils must be at the heart of efforts and in county and rural areas, county and unitary authorities are the crucial layer between translating national policy and funding into actual improvements on the ground, tailored to local place. They are big enough to convene and organise health partners, and local enough to understand and work with different communities.

“But for all the good work outlined in this study, county and rural unitary councils across the country report significant financial pressures. If we want to build on what are very solid foundations, then government needs to recognise that neighbourhood health planning in county and rural areas is distinct to planning in metropolitan areas: and provide an adequate response that fairly reflects the costs of delivering the agenda’s promises of better care, stronger communities and healthier lives.”

Law firm Browne Jacobson last week noted that the Government’s announcement encouraging councils to commission home care across smaller geographical areas would have “real legal and commercial dimensions”.

Lottie Winson

Sponsored articles

LGL Red line

Lawyer

£35,570 - £45,529 per annum (career graded post)

Newsletter signup