GLD Vacancies

SPOTLIGHT

A zero sum game?

The number of SEND tribunal cases is rising and the proportion of appeals ‘lost’ by local authorities is at a record high. Lottie Winson talks to education lawyers to understand the reasons why, and sets out the results of Local Government Lawyer’s exclusive survey.

Council to reimburse school transport costs following Ombudsman investigation

Leicestershire County Council has agreed to refund a mother’s school transport costs after an investigation by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman found “flaws in the way it handled her application”.

The woman behind the complaint had spent more than £7,000 on school transport costs for her teenage son, who has disabilities and attends the post-16 section of a special school, the report revealed.

The mother had appealed an unsuccessful application for the transport costs.

The council upheld her appeal, but the mother complained the council “refused to backdate the money she paid for her son’s transport while the council considered her appeal”, said the Ombudsman.

The Ombudsman investigated the mother’s complaint and found faults with the process the council used for both the application for transport, and for considering the appeal of the decision.

The investigation found the council took “too long to reach its initial decision on the family’s school transport application, and that the information provided to parents about timescales was misleading”.

The Ombudsman investigation also criticised the information provided by the council on its website about the appeals process, which found “a link to the appeals process did not work, and so parents had to find the forms on the website themselves”.

The report also noted problems with the length of time the council took to consider the appeal, which meant the hearing took place after the school year started.

Additionally, the family incurred a “significant financial cost” as the council took three months to arrange provision after their appeal, said the Ombudsman.

Paul Najsarek, Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, said: “When carrying out assessments and appeals for any services, councils need to ensure transparency, timeliness and accountability. But in this case Leicestershire’s school transport process was beset by delay and a lack of clear information.

“This investigation also found that this process was inherently inferior for children and young people with Special Educational Needs. Because their places are decided later in the year they have been disproportionately affected and less likely to have their appeals heard in time for transport to be put in place for the start of term.

“I am pleased Leicestershire County Council has taken on board my findings, and hope the changes it has agreed to make to its application and appeal process will ensure other children and young people with disabilities will not be adversely affected in future.”

To remedy the injustice caused, the Ombudsman recommended that Leicestershire “apologise to the family and reimburse the costs they incurred minus the personal transport budget payments received”.

It was also told to pay an additional £500 to recognise the “avoidable distress caused by the council’s poor handling of their application and appeal”.

The Ombudsman's report noted that the council will “ensure information provided to applicants is accurate”, it will “consider providing information relating to SEND transport in the relevant policy” and “consider looking at its systems to ensure any issues identified can be dealt with promptly”.

A spokesperson for Leicestershire County Council said: “We fully accept the findings of the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman. We’ve apologised to the family and we’re now actively working on addressing the other recommendations set out by the Ombudsman. We take all complaints extremely seriously and improvements in our processes are now being put in place. As with any complaint which is upheld, it ensures lessons are learned.” We won’t be making any further comment on the case.”