High Court quashes home-to-school transport arrangements put in place by council for teenager with special educational needs
- Details
Essex County Council “irrationally excluded” consideration of the impact of changed drop-off and pick-up timings on a child’s ability to access education, when it sought to alter school transport arrangements.
That finding has come from Guy Vassall-Adams KC sitting as a deputy High Court judge, in a case bright by claimant SKM, who has an Education, Health and Care Plan, by her litigation friend and mother SKW.
Mr Vassall-Adams ordered the council to reassess SKM’s transport needs.
The court heard SKM is aged 15 and has home-to-school transport whereby she is dropped off at school early (8am for an 8.30am expected arrival time and an 8.40am start time) and picked up early (at 3.15pm, rather than the end of the school day at 3.20pm).
Her mother requested these times so SKM could settle into and leave school at times when the building is less busy.
Essex wanted to change this so that the same vehicle could pick up another child, arriving at school at the normal time for all pupils.
The council refused stage 1 and 2 appeals lodged by SKW and she issued judicial review proceedings alleging breach of statutory duty under s.508B Education Act 1996.
SKM has sensory processing disorder, attention deficit disorder, oppositional defiance disorder, dyslexia and hypermobility and various other conditions that affect her education.
Essex argued that to continue to provide the journeys at earlier times with separate arrangements for the other child would cost £16,366 over a school year and it was unreasonable to expect the public purse to bear this.
The council also said the appeal was about what happens in school and not the journey itself, and so did not involve transport provision.
It said statutory guidance did not mention a child having a transition period before lessons.
Mr Vassall-Adams said the language of s.508B(1) of the Education Act 1996 and the guidance “make it clear that the purpose of placing local authorities under a duty to provide free home-to-school transport for eligible children of compulsory school age…is to facilitate their attendance at school and their access to education”.
He continued: “Other parts of the guidance also show that the focus is not just on the child's experience of the journey itself, but the impact of the transport arrangements on their ability to access education during the school day.”
Mr Vassall-Adams explained: “Unfortunately, in this case [Essex] states repeatedly in the decision that the suitability of school transport is to be assessed solely by reference to the journey itself and is not about what it has called 'in school’ needs.”
The judge said this narrow interpretation was “inconsistent with the statutory purpose and the guidance” as decisions about transport arrangements may have a major impact on a child’s ability to access education later in the school day.
Timings of drop-offs and pick-ups at school were relevant to the suitability of travel arrangements and there was clear evidence that the earlier timings made a real difference to SKM’s ability to access education during the school day.
He concluded: “By adopting a narrow approach of focussing exclusively on the journey and the moment of arrival at school, [Essex] lost sight of the statutory purpose and irrationally excluded consideration of the impact of the drop-off and pick-up timings on the claimant's ability to access education during the school day.
“This was a logical error or critical gap in [Essex]’s reasoning that undermined the decision.”
Essex had also taken “an impermissibly restrictive reading of the guidance on the basis that a child must establish that they are medically unfit to attend school for some of the school day.
“This is not what the guidance says. The guidance states that usually a local authority will not be able to accommodate separate arrangements for different start and finish times, but then goes on to say that there may be a small number of cases where it is appropriate for the local authority to arrange transport at an alternative time of day…”
Mr Vassall-Adams quashed Essex’s decision and said the council must reassess SKM’s needs.
Mark Smulian
Sponsored articles
How Finders International Supports Council Officers
How hair strand testing should be instructed for family court proceedings
Solicitor or Barrister: Education and SEN
Paralegal: Education and SEN
Lawyer
Locums




