Three councils told to apologise and make payments following poor management of proposed adoptive placement
- Details
The London Boroughs of Ealing, Hounslow and Southwark have all been criticised by the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman after failings in their management of a proposed adoptive placement.
Following the investigation, the councils agreed to implement service improvements to prevent a recurrence of the faults identified.
The couple behind the complaint, Mr and Mrs X, who are approved prospective adoptive parents, complained that the three London Boroughs failed to manage a proposed adoptive placement properly, resulting in a child, Y, not being placed with them as they had been led to expect.
Hounslow is the corporate parent for the child, Y. Ealing is the lead agency for the Regionalised Adoption Agency (RAA) called Adopt London West, of which Hounslow and Ealing are members (Hounslow commissioned Ealing to find an adoptive family for Y).
Southwark is the lead agency for another neighbouring RAA, Adopt London South, and it assessed and approved Mr and Mrs X as prospective adoptive parents.
Specifically, the couple complained that the councils:
- delayed in completing paperwork, preventing a move of Y to the complainants, as an early permanence placement;
- advised the couple to take adoption leave, without providing an adoption certificate, which the complainants then had to cancel, causing disruption to their employments;
- failed to investigate alleged physical abuse to Y by a foster carer raised by the complainants during the introduction stage;
- caused the complainants unnecessary expense by getting them to buy toys in advance of the placement and not reimbursing them for these costs;
- at the last moment, after there had been some meetings between the complainants and Y, it was decided that they were not a suitable match and there were concerns about their emotional vulnerability when this had not been previously mentioned or raised as a concern;
- delayed in collecting Y’s clothes after the proposed placement had been stopped; and
- failed to investigate the complaints properly.
The Ombudsman found fault causing avoidable distress, grief and time and trouble for the couple.
The proposed match was first considered in summer 2023. Following initial discussions, the three councils’ social workers visited Mr and Mrs X, who subsequently confirmed their interest in having Y placed with them.
Mr and Mrs X told the Ombudsman that they were put under pressure to agree to a start date for the proposed placement, and they felt any hesitation would be viewed as a lack of commitment. They said this is why they gave notice to their employers.
Mr and Mrs X told the Southwark social worker that they wanted to meet Y before taking the next step and to speak to the medical adviser.
The couple were told they could withdraw after meeting Y if they did not feel a connection. Two “meet before match” meetings subsequently took place, including one at Y’s foster carer’s home.
During the first meeting, Mr and Mrs X said that the Hounslow social worker took photographs of them without their consent or notice, which made them feel “uneasy”.
During the investigation, the Ombudsman found that the councils had not properly explained that the meetings were also an opportunity for professionals to assess the couple’s suitability.
Nor was there clear written evidence recording the interactions, the concerns raised or the analysis underpinning decisions to continue with the proposed match.
Hounslow had doubts about the suitability of the placement after the first meeting but failed to make a clear written record of those concerns. The Ombudsman also found that Hounslow and Ealing had not properly considered whether further meetings were in Y’s interests or might mislead the prospective adopters.
The meeting at the foster carer’s home was not properly observed or recorded. The Southwark social worker reportedly remained for only 30 minutes of the two-hour visit. The Ombudsman found this was a significant omission, particularly given the concerns about the proposed placement and the importance of properly observing the interaction between the couple and Y.
The investigation further found poor record keeping by Hounslow, including its failure to record meetings and visits properly and to place messages from an encrypted instant messaging application on Y’s adoption file.
Both Hounslow and Ealing were found at fault for deleting messages from the application rather than retaining them on their files.
The Ombudsman also found that Hounslow had allowed concerns about information contained in the couple’s adoption assessment report to emerge too late in the process, despite the information having been available to social workers at an earlier stage.
The Ombudsman said it could not determine whether the placement would have proceeded had the faults not occurred.
Hounslow was also found at fault for taking nearly a year to collect Y’s possessions from the couple after the proposed placement had been stopped.
On the complaints process, the Ombudsman found Hounslow should have taken the lead in a statutory investigation covering all three councils, as the corporate parent. Instead, the couple had to make three separate complaints, resulting in separate investigations.
To remedy the injustice caused, Hounslow was recommended to:
- Apologise to Mr and Mrs X;
- Make a symbolic payment of £750 to recognise Mr and Mrs X’s injustice;
- Write to Mr and Mrs X confirming that all photographs taken during the meet before match meetings have been deleted;
- Ensure that Y’s adoption file is updated with all the relevant reports, minutes of meetings and the documentary evidence about the actions taken in 2023.
Ealing was recommended to:
- Apologise to Mr and Mrs X
- Make a symbolic payment of £750 to recognise Mr and Mrs X’s injustice which includes their avoidable time and trouble in pursuing their complaints; and
- Pay their expenses because they were not told at the outset that these would not be met.
Southwark was recommended to:
- Apologise to Mr and Mrs X;
- Make a symbolic payment of £750;
- Allow Mr and Mrs X to put on their adoption assessment file their account of their last visit to Y, their account of the meeting with the psychologist (and pre-meeting with the social worker) and their subsequent communication with Southwark;
- Place a copy of the Ombudsman’s final statement on their adoption assessment file; and
- Once all the additional information is placed on the file, revise its reference which Mr and Mrs X can use if they wish to approach another adoption agency.
Responding to the report, a Hounslow Council spokesperson said: “We have accepted the Ombudsman’s recommendations in full and have apologised to Mr and Mrs X. We have also taken swift action to strengthen our practice alongside our regional adoption agency, Adopt London West, in response to the findings”.
An Ealing Council spokesperson said: “We have accepted the Ombudsman’s findings and recommendations in full and are sorry for the distress, grief, time and trouble caused to the complainants and have apologised to them for the faults and injustice which happened in this case.
“Since these events, we have taken swift action to strengthen our practice alongside our local authority partner and the other regional adoption agency including clearer guidance for prospective adopters about the matching and placement process and when formal adoption decisions are made. We have also strengthened procedures around communication, consent, record-keeping and the coordinated handling of adoption-related complaints to help ensure a more consistent experience for families.”
Southwark has been approached for comment.
Lottie Winson
Sponsored articles
How hair strand testing should be instructed for family court proceedings
How Finders International Supports Council Officers
Paralegal: Education and SEN
Lawyer
Solicitor or Barrister: Education and SEN
Locums




