Planning obligations "still most effective mechanism for affordable housing delivery" PDF Print E-mail
Thursday, 05 January 2012 00:00

Planning obligations will remain the most effective mechanism for delivering affordable housing on site and in mixed and balanced communities, the Planning Officers’ Society has said.

The claim was made in the Society’s response to a government consultation on the funding of affordable housing through the Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL).

Graham Jones, Vice-President Emeritus of POS and principal author of its response, said: “S106 agreements for affordable housing have in general significant advantages over CIL in that they can deliver sites and can be negotiated with developers to achieve a mutually acceptable outcome.

“However local circumstances will vary considerably and where local authorities have sites available, or where housing development is typically on many small sites, local authorities should have the flexibility to decide how CIL and S106 can best be utilised to deliver the best outcome."

The Society said it would reject the option of CIL being the only mechanism for delivering affordable housing.

“The ability to use obligations in this respect is critical to delivering local and national policy,” it argued. “However, in some circumstances the levy could provide much needed monies. Having the choice could therefore be of benefit in some circumstances.”

The response added that, should local authorities be permitted to use both instruments, there was a need for transparency and fairness, and a need for processes which are straightforward, practical and manageable.

The Society said it did not agree that this would be best achieved through the local plan, because of the timescales involved and the different tests applied to local plans and CIL at examination.

“It would not seem appropriate that a single aspect of CIL should be tested against soundness at LP examination while all other aspects are required only to be reasonable,” the response said.

“How an authority is to apply CIL/S106 in response to affordable housing will also have implications for its CIL charging schedule rates which are tested at the CIL examination. It would seem more straightforward and more relevant if this was a part of the CIL examination.”

The Society argued that the use of CIL/S106 obligations was an implementation issue, and while the authority's approach needed to be based on and consistent with policy as set out in the local plan there was “no need for it to be a part of the plan itself”.

On the issue of whether – if the levy can be used for affordable housing – affordable housing should be excluded from the regulation that limits pooling of planning obligations or the same limits should apply, the POS said it should be excluded.

“To only allow five affordable housing contributions would severely restrict authorities’ flexibility to deliver affordable housing,” the Society said.

A copy of the Society’s response, which also covers its views on the neighbourhood funds part of the consultation, can be downloaded here.


Latest News

July 28, 2014

Law Commission includes DoLS and Wales projects in next programme

A law reform project to consider how deprivation of liberty should be authorised and supervised in settings other than hospitals and care homes has been included in the Law Commission’s 12th programme of law reform. Read more
July 28, 2014

London borough approves abolition of its regional planning committees

The London Borough of Redbridge agreed earlier this month to abolish regional planning committees. Read more
July 25, 2014

Borough launches legal action against neighbour over failure to cooperate

Luton Borough Council has launched judicial review proceedings against a neighbouring authority over its decision to grant planning permission for a major urban extension. Read more
July 22, 2014

Housebuilder launches Planning Court challenge to neighbourhood plan

A housebuilder has launched a judicial review challenge to a neighbourhood plan with the Planning Court. Read more
July 21, 2014

Law Society delays new CON 29 and CON 29O enquiry forms

The Law Society has delayed the introduction of new CON 29 and CON 29O enquiry forms. Read more
July 18, 2014

Council slams ministers for revoking Art 4 direction on office-to-flats conversions

The London Borough of Islington has reacted angrily to a decision by ministers to revoke an Article 4 direction that the council had made removing permitted development rights to convert properties from office to… Read more
July 18, 2014

Building owner to pay £40k+ after failure to comply with enforcement notice

A building owner must pay more than £40,000 as part of a crackdown by Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea planning enforcement officers in some of London’s most exclusive areas. Read more



projects portrait1
July 24, 2014

CIL – a reminder on s106 and s278 restrictions

Caroline Bywater looks at what will happen if local authorities do not have a charging schedule in place for the Community Infrastructure Levy by April 2015. Read more
environment portrait1
July 10, 2014

Sustainable development: the Humpty Dumpty approach

Sue Chadwick looks at the challenges thrown up by the concept of 'sustainable development'. Read more
July 03, 2014

Judicial review, proportionality and s.178 direct action

A senior Court of Appeal judge has rejected an argument that proportionality was a matter for the Court on an application for judicial review of a planning authority's decision to take direct action to remove travellers. Read more
June 26, 2014

Speaking up

The High Court ruled earlier this year in a case where a non-planning councillor spoke at a planning committee meeting. Mary Tate examines the ruling. Read more
June 26, 2014

The local authorities’ perspective on fracking

David Brammer discusses the role local government has to play in awarding fracking rights and regulating the industry. Read more
June 19, 2014

Variation of planning obligations

Kamran Hyder examines s. 106BA of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the new process to modify or discharge affordable housing obligations. Read more
June 19, 2014

Heritage partnership agreements

Richard Harwood QC discusses the new power to enter into heritage agreements under s. 26A of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990. Read more
June 19, 2014

Green day

Significant rulings continue to be handed down by the courts in relation to town and village greens. Antonia Murillo reviews the latest judgments. Read more


Older news and features

June 26, 2014

Speaking up

June 19, 2014

Green day

May 15, 2014

The winning shot?

April 16, 2014

Setting planning fees

Click here for full section archive

Now Previewing on Green Belt Development - The Legal Issues (Click on bottom right of screen for full size.)

Featured Jobs

Christchurch and East Dorsets Councils
Ashford Borough Council Planning Lawyer

CLICK HERE to search all current vacancies

Featured Courses & Events

50% off LGLtv subscriptions

Sign up for Courses and Events Updates

* indicates required

Services v2

Yellow pages iStock 000009762383XSmall cropTo access details of individual advertisers, please click on the relevant banner below.

To search all entries in the Local Government Lawyer Services Directory, please click here


Ivy Legal


 Shout_to_the_top_looking_left_iStock_000006002590XSmall_98x74 Latest Blog Posts





Snap Judgement

Will the SRA's decision to remove the 16 hour minimum training requirement...