Ministers stick with Law Commission for taxi and PHV law reform project PDF Print E-mail
Monday, 17 October 2011 00:00

The government has rejected calls from MPs to fast track reform of the law governing taxis and private hire vehicles.

The transport select committee called in July for "urgent and wholesale reform" as well as new legislation to tackle cross-border hire, suggesting that ministers should use the legislative reform order route to achieve this.

But the goverment last week reaffirmed its commitment to handing the project over to the Law Commission.

The response from ministers said: “The government has indicated that it wants the review to be underpinned by a deregulatory objective commensurate with maintaining satisfactory levels of safety. Beyond that, the Law Commission has been charged with carrying out a root and branch review with a view to providing recommendations and drawing up a draft Bill.”

Ruling out the legislative reform order route, ministers said that while it expected the draft Bill produced by the Law Commission to have a good degree of support, there would be substantive and controversial issues to be addressed. It would be best if these issues were considered and debated during the passage of the Bill through Parliament, the government said.

The response also said:

  • A sensible and desirable outcome from the review would be a single Act of Parliament covering both taxis and PHVs
  • The Department for Transport will not intervene in the way local authorities review their progress against local transport plans or require reports or review. “While local authorities had a statutory duty to produce LTPs by April 2011 it will be for them to decide how to implement and use them”
  • Ministers agreed in principle with national standards in relation to issues which directly relate to public safety, such as the level of CRB check drivers require, the roadworthiness of vehicles and drivers whose licences have been revoked being licensed shortly afterward by a different district
  • Local authorities seemed well-placed to deal with this form of transport. “They have a good deal of experience and expertise in administering the licensing function and a continuing role for them would obviate the need to establish a new licensing system. However, the government does not want to pre-empt the Law Commission’s fundamental review of the legislation, and would be willing to consider the case for an alternative approach”
  • Ministers agreed that the Law Commission should review any legal barriers to co-operation between local authorities and innovation in organising and funding enforcement activity. “There would seem to be advantages in enabling local licensing authorities to collaborate over enforcement funding and activity”
  • There is merit in considering whether certain low-level offences relating to taxis and PHVs could be appropriately dealt with by fixed penalty notices
  • The government in principle accepted the MPs’ recommendation that existing licensing districts should be permitted to be combined where local authorities decide it is best to do so. However, the Law Commission would have to consider the details of  how this would work.


Related courses on

Ministers also said they understood the concerns about cross-border hire problems. But they said they were “not convinced” by a recommendation from the select committee that it should be permissible for taxi and PHV licences to include a condition that the vehicle must principally be operated in the licensing district.

The response gave a number of reasons for this, including that it “did not seat neatly with a deregulatory approach to reforming taxi and PHV legislation”. It also suggested that on a practical level, it would involve local authorities establishing a new tier of enforcement activity.

The government said it did not want to fetter the Law Commission’s discretion, but did suggest one alternative approach of obliging licensed operators to use only vehicles licensed by the same local authority as granted their operator licence.

Ministers also rejected the MPs’ recommendation that local authorities be: permitted to issue fixed penalty notices to out-of-town drivers where there is evidence, for example, that they have worked or sought to work for a specified period of that time in that district; and allowed to prosecute operators in other districts which are routinely sending cars to work in their area.

The Law Commission agreed to include the reform project in its 11th programme of law reform, which started in July 2011.

Philip Hoult



Latest News

July 21, 2014

Chelmsford City Council becomes latest authority to back late night levy

The full council at Chelmsford has approved the introduction of a late night levy in November. Read more
July 17, 2014

Philip Kolvin QC named head of Cornerstone Barristers

Philip Kolvin QC, a licensing expert and regular contributor to Local Government Lawyer, has been named as the new head of Cornerstone Barristers. Read more
July 16, 2014

Nottingham City Council approves introduction of late night levy

Nottingham City Council has become the latest authority to approve plans for the introduction of a late night levy. Read more
July 08, 2014

CAMRA and think tank urge councils to use powers to protect pubs from closure

Councils should make creative use of their powers to protect pubs from closure, a report from the Local Government Information Unit and the Campaign for Real Ale has said. Read more
July 03, 2014

Revised mandatory licensing conditions issued dealing with drinks promotions

Draft amendments to the mandatory licence conditions dealing with ‘irresponsible’ drinks promotions have been issued by the Government. Read more
June 24, 2014

Croydon mulls consultation on area-wide selective licensing for all landlords

The Cabinet at Croydon Council will next week consider issuing a consultation on a selective licensing scheme that would cover every landlord in the borough. Read more



Police photo iStockphoto standard 146x219
July 10, 2014

Power play

Greater use of existing powers could be made to deal with the consequences of late-night drinking and to target problem customers, argues Gerald Gouriet QC. Read more
Alcohol shutterstock 190326683 146x219
July 03, 2014

Recent appeals decisions under the Licensing Act

There have been a number of interesting appeal decisions under the Licensing Act recently, writes Paddy Whur. Read more
June 19, 2014

Durham - an enlightened approach to reviews

Paddy Whur approves of the approach taken to a licence review in Durham. Read more
May 15, 2014

Primary gambling activity: the FTT view

In an important decision that will impact on all betting premises licence applications the First-Tier Tribunal has given a long-awaited ruling on the meaning of 'primary gambling activity'. Gerald Gouriet QC and George Mackenzie analyse the judgment. Read more
May 08, 2014

Keep it simple! The court’s message to licensing authorities

Tim Briton, LLG's Deputy Lead Officer for Litigation and Licensing, sets out the key lessons from the Bridgerow case for local government lawyers specialising in licensing. Read more
May 08, 2014

Whose decision is it anyway?

A decision to refuse to renew a sexual entertainment venue licence was recently scuppered by a constitutional issue. Nicholas Dobson explains why. Read more


Older news and features

May 01, 2014

Calling their bluff?

April 16, 2014

No minor matter

April 02, 2014

Lap dance no more

March 13, 2014

A licence to busk

March 05, 2014

The sound and the fury

Click here for full section archive

Now Previewing on Prof Roy Light on Licensing law.  Free-of-charge to new users. Enter FREE TRIAL when checking out (registration required).

Featured Jobs

CLICK HERE to search all current vacancies

Featured Courses & Events

Sign up for Courses and Events Updates

* indicates required

Services v2

Yellow pages iStock 000009762383XSmall cropTo access details of individual advertisers, please click on the relevant banner below.

To search all entries in the Local Government Lawyer Services Directory, please click here




Woods Whur ad


 Shout_to_the_top_looking_left_iStock_000006002590XSmall_98x74 Latest Blog Posts





Snap Judgement

Will the SRA's decision to remove the 16 hour minimum training requirement...